Skip to main content
NSDF Logo NSDF
Donate
What's On
NSDF HUB
What We Do
What We Do
What is NSDF all about?
NSDF HUB NSDF CREATES Access Toolkit How to Enter a Show Our Yearly Festival The Bigger Room Project
Support Us
Support Us
How can you support NSDF's work?
Alumni Supporters Scheme Our Supporters Make a Donation Leave a Legacy
Our Story
Our Story
Find out more about the 65 year old Festival.
Our Mission Our History Our Principles Our People Our Alumni
The Fourth Wall
The Fourth Wall
Read articles from Noises Off, our Festival Magazine, and catch the latest from Team NSDF at Blogs & News
Blogs & News Noises Off
Register
Noises Off Article

A factory of art

Published on
15th April 2019

Joseph Winer analyses NSDF and the theatre industry through the lens of Fordism 

Share this article

At Saturday night's NSDF ‘19 Opening Party, Curve Chief Executive Chris Stafford said a bunch of wonderful things to welcome us to the week. He also described the festival as ‘a factory of art’. I found this uncomfortable. When we think of factory work, we often think of the mass production assembly line: unfair working conditions, quantity vs quality, and repetitive labour. Using David E. Nye’s breakdown of the assembly model (otherwise known as Fordism), I’d like to have a think through its conventions to hopefully highlight that NSDF is definitely not a factory.

1.       There is a division of labour – each worker has a set of well-defined relatively simple tasks to be performed on a car being moved along a moving assembly line

OK, so, yes, theatre is, a division of labour. There’s a production team who take on different roles for each show, a group of actors, a management team, set of skilled technicians, selectors, judges, etc. But are the tasks of these workers relatively simple as Ford’s model would suggest? Surely not. Take the role of the director for example. The car in our scenario is the show itself. There’s no clear set of instructions for the physical labour involved in the task of making a show. Unlike cars, no two shows are ever the same. Nor is the task of making our “product” a simple one. 

2.       The parts that the laborer applies in the assembly process are interchangeable. There is no ad hoc filing, grinding, etc., to make them fit in place.

Ad hoc filling, grinding – shaping to make fit the part – seem integral to the nature of many performances we’ll see this week. A production moulds its team, its set, its technology. It cuts together music tracks. It focuses its spotlights differently depending on the height of the actor...I think we can all agree that there is plenty of filling and grinding in this industry to fit everything into place.

3.       Manufacturing employs specialized machines that have a single function.

Single function…

S I N G L E fun k shun. ????? 

How many times have you been making a show and found yourself doing a job that feels completely out of your remit? I’ve seen technicians tearing ticket stubs. Front of House managers checking in on cast welfare. Actors sewing together their own costumes. In producing a show, even worker and machine become interchangeable in their functions. Our ‘factory of art’ sees creatives, technicians and all others involved both facilitate the labour and create the work itself. Unlike the factory, it is not the speed of the machine that defines our work pace. Our labour is cued by the demands of our fellow theatre-makers.

4.       Machines are not grouped by type (you don’t put all the milling machines in one spot) but are placed where they are needed.


 

Hmmmmm.

The actors are blocked. The management team are on different doors. One technician’s up a ladder. Another’s behind a sound desk. But the point is, not one of us is stuck or stable like a machine? 

 

5.       Parts and assemblies are moved automatically from one stage of production to the next — they’re not shifted by workers whose job is assembly. There is no wearisome heavy lifting or towing.


 

Just speak to any stage crew for this one. Try and run your show without a technician moving any heavy equipment around the building. We don’t just build the show. We often find ourselves running the entire operation. Particularly in the DIY budget-restricted world of student theatre. 

 

6.       There is enhancement of production by electrification and good lighting.


 

OK, perhaps I’ll give this one to Ford.

 

***

The factory model sees efficient mass production. The focus is on product. And the focus on product is to turn a profit. This is not what theatre should be about. We should be interested in process. In the failure of something going wrong on the night. In the vast range of responses that different audiences can offer for a moment in a show.


 

This is not to say we don’t have to work efficiently. Restrictions on money, rehearsal space, time-frames, etc., do force us to work under pressure. But I think it’s really boring when work is performed in the exact same way night after night. In an article for WhatsOnStage, Matt Trueman described the long running Les Misérables as ‘perfect, too perfect’, commenting on the nature of play as a medium of ‘discovery and invention’. We simply cannot play in a factory that pressures us into making product on mass. I also don’t believe that labour should always be disguised behind seamless scene transitions and “magical” thirty-second costume changes. Why should our labour be repetitive, pressured and thankless?


 

Guest Director James Phillips also referred to the extra hour of labour that the festival worker might do that goes unnoticed. But should we really be glamorising this? Is NSDF trying to set us up for an industry which, like the factory, forces its labourers into working in unjust conditions? Art is about creative expression. A masterpiece can happen by accident. An arts council funded national production can be an absolute failure. And maybe that’s OK? Maybe that’s the point?

If NSDF is a factory of art, then I’m not sure we’re doing it properly? I also demand a pay rise.

 

@noffmag / noff@nsdf.org.uk

Latest from Noises Off

Latest from Noises Off

See all
NSDF 2022

Powerful discomfort

14th May 2022

Nathan Hardie on the confronting NSDF Late show MANIC

Read More
NSDF 2022

To meet us here

15th April 2022

Taiwo Ava Oyebola interrogates the history and heritage of Them

Read More
NSDF 2022

Up down up down

15th April 2022

Zoe Callow gets to grips with the staging of Great Mother - Iya Ayaba

Read More

Sign-up to our newsletter

Sign-up for our newsletter
Follow us
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
Contact Us Frequently Asked Questions Young Person Protection Policy Website Accessibility Privacy Policy
© NSDF Site by Grandad.digital
Sign-up to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date on all our upcoming events, information and news. Read our Privacy Policy to learn more about how we process your data.