Skip to main content
NSDF Logo NSDF
Donate
What's On
NSDF HUB
What We Do
What We Do
What is NSDF all about?
NSDF HUB NSDF CREATES Access Toolkit How to Enter a Show Our Yearly Festival The Bigger Room Project
Support Us
Support Us
How can you support NSDF's work?
Alumni Supporters Scheme Our Supporters Make a Donation Leave a Legacy
Our Story
Our Story
Find out more about the 65 year old Festival.
Our Mission Our History Our Principles Our People Our Alumni
The Fourth Wall
The Fourth Wall
Read articles from Noises Off, our Festival Magazine, and catch the latest from Team NSDF at Blogs & News
Blogs & News Noises Off
Register

In the detail

Published on
22nd April 2019

Nathan Dunn zeroes in on the relationship between performer and set

Share this article

A Girl Is A Half-Formed Thing deals with tremendously difficult issues, naturally making it a difficult watch. However, its harrowing content isn’t the only cause of this difficulty.

Kate O’Gorman’s performance is impressive. She handles emotional turns with swift precision and is entirely convincing. I just wish she was a bit more…unforgiving? One of the best pieces of dramatic advice I’ve received came from one of my tutors, who remarked: ‘theatre isn’t ‘HAVE THAT’, it’s ‘come here.’’ (Unfortunately, hand-gestures cannot be placed into print.) However, in my opinion (which, alongside any advice I reference, is not infinitely unfailing) solo work is a specific medium that depends on specific controls. The room must be dominated. Totally and utterly controlled by performance. Though the aesthetic of the following concept is seductive, I can’t help but feel this play (and consequentially, the room) is far too big for the performer. An untamed style can be powerful, and in this instance it is in many ways, but when control of the room feels wild, it’s sometimes difficult to engage with.

It’s a shame that her conviction can be glossed over. Fortunately, it’s not disastrous. It doesn’t take too much away from the myriad of emotional cliffs the show conquers. It’s just that sometimes words get lost under the melodic neatness of O’Gorman’s Irish accent, and I feel like the words are reaching for the walls and ceiling but fall short. It’s arguably a simple issue of projection, though I’ll refrain from further comment because I have no interest in critiquing a performer based on how loud they are. It would be unnecessarily pedantic. Instead, I am inclined to suggest the in-set accentuates these technical, minute shortfalls. Although theatrically stimulating, the effect of a select few literally being within the inner circle of this play somewhat polarises us. Though clearly deliberate, O’Gorman’s use of these members of the audience as participants of her direct address leaves me inclined to believe that some elements of the piece fell within the boundaries of this particular space. I think knowing that I was part of a crowd who were the second hurdle in regards to navigating this dialogue as opposed to the first made it too easy to disengage.

I wouldn’t normally commit such detail to what I myself profess to be small issues. However, they permeated my viewing experience and that is what this is a reflection of. A collation of this experience would be best described as something that was bravely performed, acutely directed, technically intelligent yet blurred by forgiving facets of the play’s portrayal, both directorially and performatively. I don’t want to be left off the hook. Next time, I hopefully won’t be.

@noffmag / noff@nsdf.org.uk

Latest from Noises Off

Latest from Noises Off

See all
NSDF 2022

Powerful discomfort

14th May 2022

Nathan Hardie on the confronting NSDF Late show MANIC

Read More
NSDF 2022

To meet us here

15th April 2022

Taiwo Ava Oyebola interrogates the history and heritage of Them

Read More
NSDF 2022

Up down up down

15th April 2022

Zoe Callow gets to grips with the staging of Great Mother - Iya Ayaba

Read More

Sign-up to our newsletter

Sign-up for our newsletter
Follow us
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube
Contact Us Frequently Asked Questions Young Person Protection Policy Website Accessibility Privacy Policy
© NSDF Site by Grandad.digital
Sign-up to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter to stay up to date on all our upcoming events, information and news. Read our Privacy Policy to learn more about how we process your data.